Are you tired of being on hold, chatting with bots, and poor claim or customer service? So were we, and that’s why we started the Overmyer Insurance Agency.

Saving money on your insurance premiums is just the start. Insurance is time-consuming, costly, and complex. We make the insurance process simple and optimize your personal and business insurance experience with real agents. This is the OIA way.

Contact :

(908) 476-8685

Contact Us Today

Visit our website:


2 South Ave E
Cranford, NJ 07016

About The Company

Agents, Not Bots is the heart of the Overmyer Insurance Agency, LLC. We pride ourselves in providing you with access to a dedicated agent and advisor that keeps your best interest and protection in mind.
Working with an independent insurance agent is a different experience than using a direct or online insurance company. We are your insurance advocate and advisor, coverage knowledge base, and have the real-life insights and expertise to customize your insurance policies to provide superior asset protection that fits your life and budget.

As an independent insurance agency the Overmyer Insurance Agency is not tied down to one single insurance company, we work with many different insurance companies to find the best fit for you. The Overmyer Insurance Agency is locally based in Cranford, New Jersey, and is always customer service-focused. No need to be on hold or deal with the frustration of contacting an unknown customer service call center in the event of a claim or policy question.

Whether you have to report a claim, would like an insurance policy quote, or simply have a question, we are here for you.

Overmyer Insurance tailors the insurance coverage specific to their clients. We offer a wide range of insurance coverages for our clients :